Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Friend of homophobes, Islamists and dictators not Londoners

The Mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, has, quite famously, shared a platform with Islamists, homophobes, and communist dictators. Where exactly are his priorities?
See the latest advert about Livingstone on 18 Doughty Street. He doesn't deserve anyones vote. All allegation sources in the advert are available here.

You are now in international water... light up!

Stop Press! Douglas Alexander, in a move clearly designed to take attention away from his "Lalalala I'm not listening" over road pricing, has just announced that,
"The Government announced last year that restrictions on smoking in enclosed workplaces, public places and vehicles would be introduced in England from July. This will save thousands of lives over the next decade by reducing both exposure to hazardous second-hand smoke and overall smoking rates.

"We now intend to introduce similar provisions to provide protection from second-hand smoke for people on vessels operating in UK waters, both at sea and on inland waterways."
That's right, they plan to ban smoking on boats, how they will enforce this I really have no idea. Unless we're about to see adverts in the Guardian for Smoking Patrol troops which will hang around 6 miles off-shore doing random spot checks to make sure the fishermans' friends are not having a sly roll-up.

As far as I know, smoking is banned inside on ferries already, so god know how the second-hand smoke can even apply to a cross channel ferry a mile off the coast of Portsmouth. Thus one conclusion can be drawn.

The Department of Transport and Douglas Alexander are spinning a story of a total gimmick, unenforceable, silly policy presumably in the hope that we will all stop talking about an online petition at Downing Street that continues to grow by the hour.
Image shameless lifted from Guido

Brown prefers air over rail 97% of the time

All the papers today seem to have been carrying the news about MPs detailed travel expenses. Hence we now know that Chris Huhne, the Lib Dem Environment Spokesman, prefers to claim just over £3k in mileage by driving to Hampshire constituency instead of catching a train.

Not to be outdone on matter environmental though, Gordon Brown claimed £6,953 for air travel and just £478 for rail. Now true, his constituency is in Scotland, but given Gordon is so concerned about the environment you'd think he do better.

Mind you, his figures since 2001 don't bode well. He's claimed £47,398 for air travel and just £1,447 on rail. In 2001-02 he didn't even claim a single rail ticket and just did everything by plane. Interestingly that was same year he halved the airport tax that he's just doubled.

Update: Before anyone accuses me of being partisan. David Cameron prefers taxis over everything else and spent between £20-£25K on them over the same period.

Tom Watson outraged at whips playing politics

Over on his blog, Tom Watson MP is opining about the terrible state of affairs where the DUP have apparently forced assembly members to sign undated resignation letters in advance. Tom says,
Imagine the outcry if Labour whips forced candidates to sign an undated resignation letter and implement rules in which you can be fined up to £20,000 for not towing the line. He doesn’t know he’s born that Jeremy Corbyn.
Very true indeed, why it's almost as bad as a Labour whip orchestrating a seemingly spontaneous handful of resignations including their own, in the hope of forcing a Prime Minister to resign and bring about a bloodless coup for his political master!

"Britain" is failing its children?

That's what the opinion pieces and the general thrust of op-eds peddled as "news" say in the Independent this morning. Personally, I think it's more likely a large number of Britain's parents failing their children, but personal responsibility is not fashionable at the Indy. Better to blame the nation for not being sufficeint socialist enough. Apparently inequality is terribly high here. That's inequality of outcome you understand, not inequality per se.

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Quantum computer due today?

According to ABC News, a Canadian company, D-Wave, says that it will be unveiling a quantum computer today. Now I just happen to know a physicist who has done lots of horribly hard maths and stuff on this subject, he happens to write a blog too, so I've just asked him for his opinion.

He said let's "wait and see" but also pointed to the scientist Dave Bacon's blog where he isn't that convinced. If quantum computing is a reality it will make most current encryption a complete waste of time. What's worse is that the Canuks have it! Oh wait, they're part of the Commonwealth! Score!

Update: I should add, if this is indeed true, then Canada will find itself elevated to the top tables in the global pecking order of things.
Hat Tip: Martine Martin

Blog Wars - State side

It appears that Blog War in the Presidential nomination campaign has had it's first victim. Senator John Edwards hired blogger Amanda Marcotte aka Pandragon has resigned citing a right wing campaign against her.
I was hired by the Edwards campaign for the skills and talents I bring to the table, and my willingness to work hard for what’s right. Unfortunately, Bill Donohue and his calvacade of right wing shills don’t respect that a mere woman like me could be hired for my skills, and pretended that John Edwards had to be held accountable for some of my personal, non-mainstream views on religious influence on politics (I’m anti-theocracy, for those who were keeping track). Bill Donohue—anti-Semite, right wing lackey whose entire job is to create non-controversies in order to derail liberal politics—has been running a scorched earth campaign to get me fired for my personal beliefs and my writings on this blog.
I don't quite know the full details, but this stems from something she wrote on her blog which basically had a pop at the Catholic church. The result was bad publicty for Edward because he employed her to blog her campaign.

The lesson I guess is that if you become a paid blogger for a politician either keep it quiet (difficult), or quit whilst you're employed, for example, as I think a certain blogger did whilst Chief of Staff to David Davis's leadership campaign.

A light morning fisk of Steve Richards

Every now and again I read a column that just enrages me so much I have to do a long post on it because it so littered with annoyances. This happened when I read this morning's Independent, where Steve Richards has decided to argue about the issue of road pricing now that even more people (well over a million) have now signed the Downing Street petititon. His argument starts off by simply dismissing all those that signed the petition as "short-sighted" and intellectually "lazy" and then, amusingly, proceeds to opine utter rubbish henceforth. He says,
"There is nothing new in this. Progressive government requires strong leadership because quite often it involves taking measures that are unpopular in the short term. The upside is that genuinely progressive policies acquire popularity once they are in place. The congestion charge in London is an obvious example. Ken Livingstone took the risk against the weak populist opposition of the Tories and the silent caution of the Government. He has been vindicated subsequently, including being re-elected against a Conservative candidate who pledged to abolish the charge. Sometimes boldness is necessary even if the voters are grateful only retrospectively."
This is of course absolute and total nonsense. Londoners did not vote for Ken over Norris on the basis that one wanted to scrap the Congestion Charge and the other one didn't. It is quaintly amusing though that Richards would accuse the petitioners of being "short-sighted" and holding "lazy views" and then put forward such a reductionist argument about the outcome of an election. What actually happened is that Londoners were fooled into voting for Livingstone's manifesto on the belief that he was telling the truth when he said bus fares wouldn't go up, and that the congestion charge would remain the same. In the words of The Who, they won't get fooled again. Richards goes on,
"When the Government has dared to take risks it has also been vindicated. Indeed the level of vindication can be measured by the Conservatives' U-turns. The Tories now support policies such as the minimum wage, a London-wide elected body and the higher investment in schools and hospitals, all of which they meekly opposed. Where the Government was weak and cowardly, such as adopting a conservative foreign policy position over supporting the US in the war against Iraq, it is condemned subsequently. It is much better, surely, to be praised retrospectively for courage."
He seems to be a little confused about the nature of conservatism I think. After all, conservatism is about gradualism from the status quo based upon an instinctively averse attitude to making changes without quantifable known outcomes. Thus Conservative "U-turns" on those policies doesn't actually vindicate them at all. It simply states that they are now embedded and therefore part of the status quo, thus should be approached with a traditionally conservative attitude to change. It's a bit like all that privatisation and trade union legislation that Labour didn't reverse. They're not vindicating Tory policies by failing to roll it back, they're just acknowledging it would produce unquantifiable results to do so. Amusingly he then says,
"Transport is a crisis issue. To their credit ministers have done more than the previous Conservative administration, increasing budgets and halting the decline of the railways into what had become a decrepit Third World service. But that has been nowhere near enough. Roads are congested. Trains are over-priced and unreliable. Parts of the London Underground are a disaster area and at weekends do not appear to function at all. In some areas of the country the privatised buses are nowhere to be seen."
So lets get this straight. The transport system was crap. After ten years of Labour the transport system is still crap. The only difference is that Labour have just done more less crap less. Sorry Steve, I think that argument is crap. The fallacies really start coming out now though,
"[Road pricing] recognises that road space must be rationed. Some on the left argue that road pricing would penalise the poorest, but then offer no alternative solution. There are too many cars on a small and congested island. Road pricing would free up some space."
Just because they offer you no alternative it does not make them wrong. Let's see, couple road pricing with the inherent dependency culture fostered by tax credits amongst the poor and you instantly remove another means for social mobility. It is not for critics to offer an alternative, it for policy wonks to solve the much greater issue of restricting the free movement of the already Government-nurtured underclass. There was me naively thinking that the Left cared about the many, not just the few at the top. Richards has kindly helped me out with that perception though,
"The policy should not be seen as a sacrifice, a mistake made too often when new charges are introduced. On the contrary, for selfish reasons I want fewer cars on the roads so I can get to places more quickly."
To quote the ever wise Edmund Blackadder, "Toffs at the top, plebs at the bottom, and me in the middle making a fat pile of cash out of both of them." OK, maybe he won't be making cash, but the inherent point remains, don't bother with aspiration if you're poor, just accept your tax credits, stay in your sink estate, and let us more important elite snobs have our roads back because we can afford them. Pull the ladder up Jack! Richards then starts using London as an example again (I wonder if he actually lives there?),
"Secondly, the revenues from road pricing should be earmarked exclusively for improvements to public transport and cycle lanes. The cash should not disappear in a vacuum. Again, Livingstone points the way by spending cash from the congestion charge on buses in London. The capital is the only part of the country where bus usage is up."
Why do you think buses are so popular in London right now though? Is it because of all the lovely "investment"? No, it's up because all the cars have moved to the outskirts of the congestion zone blocking them up. We don't take the bus out of choice. We do it because we have no choice at all. This said, Richards then proceeds on to his "critque" (and I use the term loosely) of the philosophical argument against road pricing, he states that,
"The civil liberty arguments are a red herring. Some worry that the Government will know where everyone is driving. So what? Unless we are driving to rob a bank I doubt if some imaginary secret police force will be very interested. The Government is having problems sorting out tax credits and tracing foreign prisoners. Everyone is far too busy to make use of film footage of motorists heading for Waitrose or a dodgy motel to conduct some sordid affair. Presumably, there will be no road pricing cameras in the motel to check up on any further mileage."
Oh dear oh dear.... firstly, just because the current administration is utterly incompetent it does not mean that we should build the technological infrastructure to allow a future non-incompetent Government to control and monitor our every move. It would be false to assume that incompetence today will exist in perpetuity. Ask yourself this, would someone like Stalin have found a system that could monitor everyone in their cars useful?

Now, as for this supposed "red herring", using humour to essentially put forward the age old "if you've got nothing to hide, you've nothing to fear" argument, he's actually completely missing the point. Information about ourselves, where we are, and what we are doing is ours, it is not the states'.

We have autonomy over that information and we make the choice when we disclose it. For example, we choose to let supermarket marketing people know what we buy by accepting the loyalty card. We will have no choice over any tracking ability. It matters not whether someone is looking at it or not. It is about the relationship between the state and the individual.

We, as individuals, are the ultimate creators of the state; and we, as individuals are the ultimate arbiters of our information, not the state. It is not about how the information may or may not be used, it is about the assumption of who owns that information in the first place. Richards finally closes his article at this point by saying,
"The petition against road pricing will be scaring everyone from Blair downwards. Yet this Government prevails when it is genuinely bold and stumbles when it pretends to be courageous. It deserves credit for contemplating radical measures. Now it must implement them."
Well excuse me, but I fail to see what is radical about a Labour government introducing another tax for the purposes of spending. Surely that is simply acting to type?

This post also appears on The Fisk

Monday, February 12, 2007

The Chomsky Prize

Danny Finkelstein has another of his competitions over here. It's the Chomsky Prize, dedicated to rules of life that we all follow and inspired by Danny's own "Never read a book or watch a film that has been recommended by Noam Chomsky.".

I have submitted mine which is basically that the phrase "it's my round" will always ensure that you don't get your head kicked in during a pub "discussion". Another would have to be, never drink red wine and port during the day, it will end in a messy way.

Any other ideas submit them.

Health and Safety fascists react to slur on their good name?

The other week, I posted about the amount of compensation the HSE pays out to staff and public for personal injuries. On Saturday, the Times ran a piece about information it had received via an FoI request which shows the HSE has a far higher number of workplace related accidents than your average organisation. The Sunday Mirror then followed it up.

Basically, the HSE was shown to have a massive rate of accidents per head which worked out to 4,143 workplace accidents per 100,000 people in 2005-2006 compared with just 2,143 in industry. Funny isn't it? Accidents included someone getting a bruised eye when a toilet roll dispenser fell on them (The mind boggles about the circumstances that happened in!).

Anyways, it seems the HSE has not got a little bit upset by all the newspaper crowing over it being a riskier place to work than a a poorly managed sausage factory. To counter the finger-pointing and laughing they have issued a press release which basically says everyone is being terrifically unfair, and their record is only bad because they record accidents better than everyone else.

That's us all told then!